If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the Forum Rules. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to visit from the selection below.
Welcome to RPGamer's new forums running under Vanilla Forums! If you're run into any odd or strange issues after our software migration please see this thread for details

Fixing Golden Sun

CadianCadian oh god who are you peopleBack and forth between New York and VermontFull Members
edited August 2014 in Role Playing Games
We all know Golden Sun, correct? Cool.

Fun fact: Golden Sun was my first JRPG (not counting Pokemon); I didn't discover Final Fantasy until I was in high school. It's always had a special place in my heart because of this, until about a year ago, when I decided to do a challenge run through Golden Sun and The Lost Age where I collect the absolute bare minimum number of Djinn (Flint and Fizz in GS, Echo, Spring, and Shade in TLA). Having played more JRPGs since my previous playthrough, the game's flaws became more apparent. The story and characters, for instance, I found phenomenally uninteresting, but let's focus on the gameplay and character customization - the Djinn system.

For those who need their memories refreshed, throughout Weyard (the land of Golden Sun) are a grand total of 72 elemental critters to collect and equip called Djinn. Djinn can be in one of three different modes - when they're in Set, they can change the stats and class of the Adept whom they're equipped on, as well as grant access to different kinds of Psynergy. Using a Djinni's unique ability in battle sends it into Standby mode. Standby Djinn don't impact an Adept's class, stats, or Psynergy, but can either be put back into Set or be used to summon creatures to deal massive damage to all enemies. After being summoned, they enter Recovery mode, where they can't be used for anything until they automatically return to Set mode.

I have to say, I actually think Golden Sun's class system is pretty neat. I really like the idea of these elemental tokens that can be mixed and matched and rearranged for different class and party combinations. The problem is that unless you need to teach an Adept Growth to get past an obstacle, there is absolutely no reason to experiment with it - all you need are the summons. Golden Sun's damage calculation is kind of odd - when it comes to summons, the higher the maximum HP of the enemy, the more damage summons do, so even the lowest class of summons, while nearly useless for random battles, still deal good amounts of damage against bosses. And as soon as you get three or four Djinn per element, even the random battles become a joke. All you need to do is spam your strongest summons, run around a bit so your Djinn recover, put them back into Standby, and repeat. To be fair, several of the bonus bosses in The Lost Age are designed with this summon spam tactic in mind (I hate you, Star Magician.) but it's a shame the gameplay that comes before them doesn't have that level of challenge.

Golden Sun certainly is not the only game to feature a summon mechanic, but it any other game that features them, they usually have high costs attached to them via MP or mana or charges, and can't be restored simply by running around for a few seconds. It's also not the only game to feature a ridiculous game-breaking mechanic, but not a lot of them give you that mechanic as early as Golden Sun gives you your summons. Spellblade, Dual-Wield, Rapid Fire, Dualcast, and Mix might be game-breaking in Final Fantasy V, but they aren't usually unlocked until the tail end of the game, after a fair amount of grinding, or both.

Even without the summons, some of the Djinn's abilities are just ridiculous. It's fine that they feature unique abilities that Psynergy can't typically cover, like Kite, which grants its target two actions the following turn, or Lull, which automatically ends the turn when it's used - these can open the way to some interesting strategies. But what about Flash, Granite, or Shade, which reduce all incoming attacks that turn to scratch damage? You can win pretty much any battle in the game by doing the following:

Turn 1 - Isaac uses Granite, everyone else attacks.
Turn 2 - Isaac sets Granite, Garet uses Flash, Ivan and Mia attack.
Turn 3 - Isaac uses Granite, Garet sets Flash, Ivan attacks, Mia heals if necessary.
Go back to Turn 2.
Repeat.

(I know that thanks to the class system, anyone can be a healer, but come on. You're going to keep things monoelemental, Mia's going to be the healer.)

It really is a shame that the summons are the focus of the gameplay instead of the classes, but I think there might be an interesting fix to this system - removing the summons entirely, and the Standby phase along with it, having only Set and Recovery. When Djinn are in Set, they work the way they already do, but using their abilities in battle puts them directly into Recovery. And instead of being queued up for Recovery like the current system, where one Djinni recovers per Adept per turn, each Djinni would have its own unique recovery time, with the Djinn that feature basic attacks or light healing recovering much faster than the barrier or revival Djinn.

Psynergy would work the same way it already does, but if you want to use the really powerful Djinn abilities, you need to decide whether it's worth X turns in a weaker class. This system probably has some flaws to iron out, and yes, you would lose the pretty summons, but it could potentially result in a more balanced gameplay system that emphasizes prediction and risk management over abusing overpowered abilities. I have RPG Maker VX Ace, so I might mess around with something like this.

Thoughts?
Twitters! Steams! Tumblrs!
3DS Friend Code: 1435-5875-0306
Brave Frontier Player ID: 6146529113
Competitive Pokemon list - if you'd like tiny Lv. 1 versions, let me know!

Comments

  • Rya_ReisenderRya_Reisender Solipsist Snowflake Full Members
    edited August 2014
    For me as one of the biggest Camelot fans (I just thought about Golden Sun on the way to work today, true story!), it's actually cool to meet someone who has Golden Sun as his first game (mine was Shining Force 1, yeah I'm old).

    Honestly, I liked Golden Sun start to finish and never thought it was too easy because of summons. I still like the system they used a lot more than a normal MP system. Djinn recovery is cool and ensures you have to worry less about resource management and can focus on just winning individual battles. I also don't mind that games allow to be "broken" by certain combinations. It's just like a cheat, nobody is forced to use it, but it's nice that it's there (I never understood the complaint about Vanish+Doom in FFVI either).
    While I can't say I'm the biggest fan of the Djinn system (it's just that Camelot games started out as really simple and playable for everyone and then continously increases in complexity, already in the Saturn era), but for Golden Sun... I just wouldn't say it should be removed. Maybe increase the recovery time a little so you can't use the same attack pattern in each battle. And maybe make random encounters a bit harder (I wonder if Camelot got scared of making the games hard because of the bad reception of Beyond the Beyond?).

    Also out of curiosity, did you ever play Beyond the Beyond? Because Golden Sun without the summons and a lot harder is basically what Beyond the Beyond is.
Sign In or Register to comment.